What is the “trick” in “trickle down” economics? It’s how wealthy elites and their neoliberal lackeys convince you that what’s good for them (tax cuts, deregulation, etc.) is good for you… and that policies like the minimum wage, overtime, and paid sick leave will ruin the economy. Economics is a story we tell ourselves to help explain who gets what, and why. In this episode we explore how to tell a better story.

Yuval Harari: Author of international bestsellers: Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind, Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow, and 21 Lessons for the 21st Century. Professor in the Department of History at Hebrew University of Jerusalem. PhD from the University of Oxford.

Twitter: @yuvalharari
Facebook: @Prof.Yuval.Noah.Harari
Instagram: @yuval_noah_harari

Molly Crockett: Director of the Crockett Lab, Assistant Professor of Psychology at Yale University, and Distinguished Research Fellow at the Oxford Centre for Neuroethics. PhD in Experimental Psychology from the University of Cambridge.

Twitter: @mollycrockett

Further reading:
(1) https://democracyjournal.org/magazine/41/a-threat-not-a-theory/
(2) https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/07/18/to-my-fellow-plutocrats-you-can-cure-trumpism-215347

Transcript:

Speaker 1: We’re so good at doing things that are very selfish, while at the same time convincing ourselves that we’re doing the most moral possible thing.

Speaker 2: We’ll trickle down a few crumbs from the masters table to get some of them through one or two Christmas shopping seasons, and let’s tell them that they can do their taxes on a postcard.

Donald Trump: Our massive tax cuts provide tremendous relief for the middle class and small business.

Speaker 4: What people [00:00:30] have to recognize is that these stories that are told, often are not told because they are true, they’re told because they’re the most effective way ever devised for elites to continue to gain advantage and keep other folks down.

Speaker 5: From the offices of Civic Ventures in downtown Seattle, this is Pitchfork Economics, with Nick Hanauer, confessions of an American capitalist caught on tape.

David Goldstein: [00:01:00] I’m David Goldstein, Senior Fellow at Civic Venture.

Hey Nick. So last episode we learned that Econ 101 is a lie, but of course most people don’t actually take Econ 101, they get the sort of popularized version of it which is trickled down economics. So, so what is trickle down economics and what’s the trick?

Nick Hanauer: [00:01:30] Yeah, so trickle down economics is sort of the popular form or narrative of something even deeper, which is neoliberalism. And trickle down economics is a set of interconnected claims that have been advanced by first some economists and then some by some very rich people who harness their self interest to those claims and finally by political leaders. And trickle down economics, the most famous instantiation of [00:02:00] it is the idea that tax cuts for rich people create growth and the corollary, tax increases for rich people will kill growth. 

David Goldstein: That’s great for you. 

Nick Hanauer: Exactly.

And there’s another instantiation of trickle down economics, which is that raising wages for workers will kill jobs, and the corollary, if you lower wages for workers or for instance, eliminate the minimum wage, it will create jobs.

David Goldstein: Okay, so [00:02:30] lowering wages, that’s bad for me.

Nick Hanauer: And finally that regulation kills jobs and growth, that any way in which we constrain the activity of wealthy people or big corporations that will be bad for economic growth. 

And these are the stories that have been advanced by economic elites for the last 30 or 40 years, and they are what pass for solid economic thinking in our culture and in our politics. [00:03:00] And they frame up how most people think about economics and therefore they have had a massive influence on the policies that we have enacted as a country basically based on these ideas. 

David Goldstein: So then as I understand it, if we cut your taxes, Nick, and we lower my wages and we deregulate all of your companies-

Nick Hanauer: That would be good for you.

David Goldstein: It’s going to be good [00:03:30] for me. Right. That’s some trick.

Nick Hanauer: It is an amazing trick. And this trick has been used by economic elites as long as there has been capitalism. And the basic trick is what’s good for me is good for you, and what’s good for you is bad for you.

David Goldstein: Man, I can’t win.

Nick Hanauer: Exactly. And I can’t lose. And that’s the trick in trickle down economics.

David Goldstein: And that’s the last 40 years in a nutshell.

Nick Hanauer: Exactly. [00:04:00] And a lot of other epochs in human history. the trick in trickle down is getting the broad public to believe that anything that benefits elites is good for the society in general and for less fortunate people in particular, and anything that in any way constrains elites will damage the entire society.

David Goldstein: Just going to hurt the people we’re trying to help.

Nick Hanauer: Exactly.

David Goldstein: You break down trickle down into three categories. Tax cuts for the rich, [00:04:30] wage suppression for everybody else, and deregulation of powerful interests now. But I’d always understood trickle down as simply the tax cuts part. I got taxes and it’ll trickle down to me.

Nick Hanauer: That’s the most well understood form is tax cuts for rich people will trickle down to workers and wages. And you saw that claim used pervasively, extensively, criminally in the tax fight that we had when [00:05:00] the Republicans push through this giant, $1.5 trillion tax cut for rich people and sold it as a thing that will create more jobs and higher wages for poor people. 

Donald Trump: My administration is working every day to lift the burdens on our companies and on our workers so that you can thrive, compete, and grow. And at the very center of that plan is a giant, beautiful, [00:05:30] massive, the biggest ever in our country, tax cut. 

Nick Hanauer: Consider how interesting it is, how necessary those folks thought it was to make the argument that the point of the tax cuts was not to enrich the rich, right? That was not an argument they made. They did not say-

David Goldstein: No, no, no. I’m supposed to get a $4,000 raise.

Nick Hanauer: Exactly.

Donald Trump: Our Council of Economic Advisors estimates that this change [00:06:00] along with a lower business tax rate would likely give the typical American household around a $4,000 pay raise, and that’s money that’ll be spent in our economy. 

Nick Hanauer: It super important to them to make that the anchor or pitch of the tax cuts. So, trickle down economics always takes this same form and so on the issue of wages, it is expressed in that very way. The idea that raising the [00:06:30] minimum wage, for instance, will kill jobs and harm the very people it’s intended to help is just another way of expressing that very same idea that anything that benefits rich people is good for the broader society. Anything that harms rich people is bad for the broader society and the fight over wages is litigated in this way, this basic claim and again and again and again that anytime you raise wages, it will reduce jobs and therefore be harmful to the broader economy. And [00:07:00] it’s just not true. There’s no empirical evidence for it, but it is an incredibly effective intimidation tactic, which is how people should think about it and experience it.

David Goldstein: So we could really extend this trickle down ethos to just about any policy. Universal healthcare, it’s just going to hurt the people.

Nick Hanauer: Exactly.

David Goldstein: It’s supposed to help.

Nick Hanauer: It’ll kill the healthcare system.

David Goldstein: Yeah. A universal free public college.

Nick Hanauer: Yeah. That will be terrible for everybody. [00:07:30] Yeah. With the opponents of these policies never say is, “We don’t care about you and we don’t want to pay more taxes, and we don’t care if life is good for you or not.” They always say, “No, no, no, no, we could do that, but then it would be bad for you.” And again, that’s the trick and trickle down.

David Goldstein: So now you’ve described trickle down as both and narrative and a story, and you’re not using these words just in passing. This is really important to understanding how [00:08:00] trickle down works in.

Nick Hanauer: A big theme of our podcast is that economics is much less a science than people have been led on to believe, that in many ways economics is simply the story we tell ourselves, that instantiates are social and moral preferences about status, privileges, and power. That story in our society and pretty much in every society is a story usually made up [00:08:30] by elites. For those elites. It in fact protects and extends the advantages that elites enjoy in society. And trickle down economics is a perfect example of that.

And what people have to recognize is that these stories that are told often are not told because they’re true, they’re told because they’re the most effective way ever devised for elites to continue to gain advantage and to keep other folks down. [00:09:00] And nothing could be truer than that about trickle down economics. 

Speaker 8: The theory is that if we make the rich richer somehow, they will let a part of their prosperity trickle through to the rest of it. And the second theory, and I suppose the second theory goes back to the days of Noah, I won’t say to the days of Adam and Eve, because they had a less complicated situation they faced. But very, very [00:09:30] early in the history of mankind, there was that second theory that if we make the average our time comfortable, and make them secure in their existence, then their prosperity will rise upward through the ranks.

David Goldstein: When you tell a better story, you end up with better policies. And when you get better policies, you get a better economy.

Nick Hanauer: Right. Exactly. And so we’re really excited today to have an amazing thinker and writer, [00:10:00] the Israeli historian, Yuval Harari, who is the author of a couple of amazing books, first Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind, and second, Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow. He hast a latest book just out, 21 Lessons From the 21st Century.

Dr. Harari, [00:10:30] how are you? 

Yuval Harari: I’m fine, thank you. 

Nick Hanauer: You have been very busy. 

Yuval Harari: Oh yeah. Too busy I think. 

Nick Hanauer: Dr. Harari, as you may know, we’re in the social change business and particularly around economic policy and economic ideas. And your first book Sapiens, had a huge impact on our thinking and in particular the way in which your historical perspective [00:11:00] informs both how human beings, why we are different from other creatures and how we have evolved using a culture created by shared stories, inter subjective realities, and imagined orders, has enormous explanatory power. And we would love for you to just talk about that a little bit. 

Yuval Harari: Yeah, I would be happy to. [00:11:30] Well, where do we start? Usually, when people try to understand the superiority of homo sapiens, of humans to other animals, they tend to think on the individual level as if there is something special about my body or my brain that is so superior to the brain of a chimpanzee or to the brain or a pig or at an elephant, but in fact on the individual level, we are not so special and we are not significantly better or [00:12:00] even at all better than other animals. 

What really makes us unique is the amazing ability to cooperate flexibly in very large numbers. We can cooperate in millions and billions, whereas no other social mammal can approach us. The social instincts can cooperate in thousands, but they lack flexibility. They can’t change the way their society functions. It takes millions of years of evolution to change the society, [00:12:30] whereas we just have a revolution and can change society within a few years. 

Now, what gives us this amazing ability to cooperate flexibly in large numbers is our ability to create and spread and believe in fictional stories. If you examine any large scale human cooperation, whether religion, a church, or a corporation or a trade network, you will always discover that it is founded, [00:13:00] it is based on fictional stories. Stories about entities that don’t exist anywhere except in the shared imagination of human beings. Entities like gods, nations, corporations, money. To take maybe the last example of money, money is not an objective reality. You can’t eat or drink or do anything useful with these dollar bills. The only reason [00:13:30] people value them is because they believe in the stories about the dollar, the stories told by the most important and most successful storytellers of all, which are the bankers and the chairperson of the Federal Reserve and so forth. And I’m not saying it’s bad, this is what enables billions of complete strangers to trade and cooperate effectively because they all believe in the same story about the dollar. 

[00:14:00] Chimpanzees can’t do it. A chimpanzee can trade, can barter. But, I give you a cocoa nut and you give me banana. This can work with chimpanzees, but it demands a lot of trust and an intimate knowledge of one another. If two strange chimpanzees meet, they cannot trade because they have no trust. They have nothing in common. 

But if now I go halfway around the world and meet a complete stranger because we both trust [00:14:30] in the story of the dollar, we can trade and we can cooperate. 

Nick Hanauer: It’s a remarkable thing. And one of the really amazing ways in which you explained this so effectively in your first book was just reminding us that we’ve always had these stories and the Code of Hammurabi being one of the best examples [00:15:00] from earlier human civilizations, and how that story was both fictional, but accepted as essentially objective reality by the people of that time and put place values in all the elements in society, in a pretty prescribed way. 

And we look back at that story and read it and think, “Well, these things are insane and ridiculous,” but it is insane and ridiculous [00:15:30] to value a woman’s life at 30 shekels or whatever it was. But we do exactly the same thing today. Our economy is constructed and in precisely the same way and saying that a person who works in a restaurant in the United States of America is simply worth $2.13 plus tips is no less arbitrary than calling a woman’s life worth 30 shekels. And that is, [00:16:00] for us, was for us a really remarkable and powerful realization. 

Yuval Harari: Yeah, of course. The underlying story today is that we didn’t decide that this person is worth $2. It’s market forces that decided it. And markets are objective and natural and they are not a fictional story. But the story of the free market is also just a story. In reality, there [00:16:30] is never such a thing as a completely free market. If you try to create the Utopian free markets and market, in which there are no regulations, in which everything can be bought and sold, and it’s market forces that determined the value of everything, then these markets a very quickly collapse because one of the things you can buy and sell on such a free market is the quotes. 

Why make an exception for the quotes? This is also [00:17:00] something, they don’t sort of commodity. So if I’m richer, I can pay the judge. If we have a disagreement about the contract, I can pay the judge and it’s a free market. Whoever pays the highest price and what is the price of ruling in my favor, wonderful. 

But very soon trust will collapse and you will not have any market at all. So unless the market is backed by some other institutions, it cannot function. So the idea that no, the markets [00:17:30] are completely objective, they determined in a natural way, irrespective of human belief, what is the value of everything? This is just another fiction.

Nick Hanauer: Yes. And again, one of the really profound insights for me anyway was, I think you called it the iron law of history, that these stories are always anchored by one of few claims. Either God says, or it’s a law of nature.

Yuval Harari: [00:18:00] Yes. Those are the two main options.

Nick Hanauer: Yeah.

Yuval Harari: Either God said it or this is how nature functions. And in most cases, if you find references to nature in a book of law and not of biology, most of the time it is not nature, it is cultural. It’s just people don’t want to admit that this is a cultural fabrication, so [00:18:30] they say no, it’s a natural law. 

Nick Hanauer: Yeah. And, that one graph in that one book explained for me the prior 10 years of frustration that I’ve had. So we have been litigating among other things the minimum wage and the thousands of emails, hate mail, tweets, Facebook postings that I’ve gotten from people who say things “Look, simply [00:19:00] don’t understand the law of supply and demand, that if wages go up, jobs will go down.” And recognizing why it was so important to those folks that it be essentially a natural law, that, that anchored essentially their entire inter subjective reality. And what’s the thing [00:19:30] that essentially enables the way in which we have organized status, privileges and power in our society.

Yuval Harari: It releases you from responsibility, from ethical and political responsibility. Hey, we didn’t decide it. It’s nature. This is how things are. What do you want?

Nick Hanauer: Yeah, these people are poor because it’s a law of nature. I had nothing to do with it. It’s super fascinating.

So here’s a question for you. There is not [00:20:00] a better example of an imagined order or an inter subjective reality than economic theory. It is a construct created mostly for and by elites to enforce status relationships that the society prefers. But there is part of economics which is truly scientific and I often struggle to distinguish between the part [00:20:30] of economics, which is an imagined order, essentially just a story we tell ourselves to enforce status constructs and the actual science part of economics, which I think is a much less important part, but a part nonetheless. Have you ever considered that distinction? 

Yuval Harari: Obviously there are many, many things which are true, which are [00:21:00] objectively true, and they are not some inter subjective construct. You just count how much wheat a particular field, a particular country produced last year, than there are objective facts there.

Nick Hanauer: Correct.

Yuval Harari: But as you move from the realm of counting wheat to the realm of explaining the laws of economics and how everything functions and where value [00:21:30] comes from, and so forth, then you gradually enter the inter subjective realm, in which the imagination and fiction plays a more and more important a part. I would emphasize however, that there is nothing wrong with fictions and stories and so forth. You can’t organize any large scale human system without it. You can’t play basketball unless you have 10 people agreeing on laws, which are completely [00:22:00] imaginary. They don’t come from physics or biology. We invented them. You can’t similarly have a trade network unless you agree on some rules and laws, and most of these rules and laws of course are invented by human beings. 

Nick Hanauer: Yes. One of the reasons we’re such huge fans is that your historical perspective on this gives somebody like me, the confidence that these fictions can and should be changed [00:22:30] over time, to improve the way in which they affect people’s lives. 

Yuval Harari: Yeah, and they have changed. If you look at essentially a century ago, two centuries ago, so you go to 19th century England, and you have all these arguments about again, nature, that people say it’s not good to have a 8-year-old kids working in coal mines. And people would come and say, “Well, this is the law of supply and demand. This is done by nature. You can’t change it. If you now have a regulation [00:23:00] that 8-year-old kids cannot work in coal mines than the French will do it and we will be left behind. So we must do it.”

And this was a very forceful argument. But eventually child labor was abolished. And everybody now looked back and say, “Hey, it was actually a great idea to send the kids to school and not to the coal mine. It actually encouraged economic growth because they started [00:23:30] inventing and doing all kinds of things. But they couldn’t if they just stayed in the coal mine.”

David Goldstein: Today, we can’t raise taxes on corporations where the rich because that would destroy growth and kill jobs, but if we tell a different story, a different shared mythology, we can change that imagined order, right? 

Yuval Harari: There is always a tension [00:24:00] between the stories people tell and what is actually happening. So you have the priest coming and saying, “Okay, if we dance this rain dance, there will be rain” and he manages to convince everybody and they dance the rain dance and there was no rain. So eventually, you do have to confront reality and not every story about the economy or the social system will actually work. But it is very important to realize that we are not dealing here with [00:24:30] natural laws. So we need to have a discussion about what economic system to have, whether to raise taxes on the rich for example. 

But this discussion should be based on the understanding that these are not natural laws. There is no law of nature which says you can’t attack the rich. All these things, they are human decisions. You can make very wrong decisions. We do have a lot of examples of people trying to do an economic revolution [00:25:00] and destroying the economy. If you look at, I don’t know if Venezuela recently, or what is now happening in Turkey, so it’s very dangerous just to think, “Okay, let’s just change the narrative and do what we want.” There is still reality out there. But we should also be aware of the opposite view that you cannot change anything because nature decreed that the way things are is natural, and any attempt to change even a little thing, will break the laws of nature and everything will collapse. 

David Goldstein: Well, [00:25:30] I think one of the most profound things that you explained to me in Sapiens was when you said that capitalism was based on faith in an imaginary future that is always bigger and more prosperous than the present. What happens when we stop believing? 

Yuval Harari: If we stop believing, we are not yet there, if we stop believing, everything will collapse. Even actually today, most of the money that exists [00:26:00] today in the world is credit. And credit is in effect is belief that the future will be better. If you don’t believe the future will be better than now, better in the sense that we produce more, we’ll be more wealthy, then the amount of credit in the system is zero. You can’t give credit. What you have now is what you have. You’ll never have more.

Now over the last few centuries in belief in the future, and this belief had good reasons behind it, it’s not arbitrary, [00:26:30] the economy did grow in an enormous way over the last few centuries mainly thanks to scientific progress, but the result is that now almost all the money in the world and all the wealth in the world is his credit. And if suddenly people stop believing that the future will be better, it’s not that we will stay where we are, but everything will collapse. Most of the money that you see in your bank account will evaporate. 

Nick Hanauer: [00:27:00] For some of us, that’s a terrifying idea. 

David Goldstein: Yeah. For those of you with the money.

Nick Hanauer: Yeah.

David Goldstein: This is why the Pitchforks are coming, Nick.

Yuval Harari: It’s terrifying for everybody. Look, if you don’t have anything in your bank account, you should also be terrified because in such a situation, all social order will also collapse. And usually when social order collapse, it’s the weakest member of the society that suffer the most, [00:27:30] so don’t wait for it with gleeful eyes because if this happens, it will be terrible. 

Nick Hanauer: Yeah. Dr. Harari, thank you so much for giving us so much of your time and thanks for doing all that great thinking. It’s been a very fun and inspirational to follow your work.

Yuval Harari: Thank you. Thank you for having me. 

Nick Hanauer: Hope to meet you some day. Take care.

Yuval Harari: Yeah. I hope so too. Take care.

Nick Hanauer: Okay, take care. Bye.

Yuval Harari: Bye-bye. 

David Goldstein: So what I learned from that Nick, [00:28:00] is that stories really are important. And when Dr. Harari says that if we stop believing in capitalism, it ceases to function, it all falls apart?

Nick Hanauer: Yes, yes indeed. And stories are everything, and whether it’s a belief in money, a belief in contracts, a belief in government, all of these beliefs are what knit societies together and make them go. And when belief collapses, societies collapse. It’s something to think about, carefully.

David Goldstein: [00:28:30] and to make a believable story, you’ve got to structure it in a certain way, right? Not every story is believable.

Nick Hanauer: That’s right. And because human beings are largely moral creatures, we live in society with norms and laws, those stories have to be ethical stories. They have to be moral stories. And so today, as I mentioned before, our guests will be Molly Crockett, one of the nation’s leading neuropsychologist [00:29:00] who will talk to us about human moral reasoning and why it’s so important for these stories to take this form, 

Molly Crockett: I’m Dr. Molly Crockett and I am an assistant professor of psychology and Yale University. I have a lab where we study human morality in the lab and also out in the wild and we’re interested in understanding [00:29:30] how we make decisions that affect ourself and other people, how we judge the behavior of others, and what kinds of stories we tell ourselves about why we do the things we do. 

David Goldstein: Great.

Nick Hanauer: So cool. So let’s start with the neoclassical idea of human behavior, which is this idea of homo economicus, that people are perfectly rational, calculating, and selfish, atomized individuals. So tell us about that. 

Molly Crockett: [00:30:00] Well, there’s been a lot of research over the past few decades trying to butt up against this idea of homo economicus. And the idea is of social preferences, which was pioneered by many economists, including my postdoc advisor, [inaudible 00:30:18], really emphasize the idea that value is more than just material value, that when people make decisions [00:30:30] and they’re trying to maximize utility or value for themselves, that includes not just for example, how much money they’re getting out of the transaction, but also what is the social context of that transaction. Is it fair or is it unfair? Who is the other person? 

And one of the classic experiments that started to chip away at the homo economicus model was the ultimatum game. The ultimatum game is very simple and you’ll probably recognize [00:31:00] a lot of everyday interactions in this model. So there are two players in the game, the proposer and the responder. The proposer has control over a resource, a pile of money and they make a proposal to the responder about how to divide up that money. The responder then has the option to accept the proposal, in which case both players are paid accordingly, or the responder can reject [00:31:30] the offer and that has the result of burning all the money. So neither player gets anything. 

So the homo economicus model would predict that the proposer should offer the lowest amount of money possible to the responder because the responder being rational will accept any non zero amount of money because something is better than nothing. Turns out that’s not what happens at all when you get actual humans to play the ultimatum game. What happens is that responders [00:32:00] will reject offers that are below 30 to 40% of the total pie. So what they think is unfair, they’ll reject, and proposers correctly into this, and they on average offer between 30 and 40%. 

And this pattern of behavior has been observed hundreds and hundreds of times in cultures all over the world with a range of amounts of money. So there were some experiments [00:32:30] done in developing countries were western researchers would fund the research and they would offer the players sums of the money that in local currencies where as much as a month’s wages, people would reject that if they thought it was unfair. 

So, this is a very, very robust human behavior. We found in some of our research as others have found as well, that when responders reject an unfair [00:33:00] offer, this activates reward circuitry in the brain. So despite the fact that they’re getting no money out of the transaction, it actually produces a brain signature that looks it feels good to burn the money rather than be on the losing end of unfair deal. 

Nick Hanauer: Yeah. So the actual brain chemistry takes over, almost.

Molly Crockett: Yeah.

Nick Hanauer: So that’s so fascinating. Molly, why do you think that we evolved to behave [00:33:30] in this way? 

Molly Crockett: Well, cooperation is one of the most adaptive and advantageous strategies that humans have developed. And humans as a species are far more cooperative than most other species. We cooperate on a scale that’s really quite rare in the animal world with the exception of of hyper social insects, like bee colonies in ant colonies. Still, human cooperation is really special and we [00:34:00] cooperate not just with our own family members, but with people that we’ve never met, will never meet again, Single transactions, economies are built on this, and so cooperation is thought to evolve because it really does confer benefits on individuals and groups and within groups. If you are an individual who gets a reputation for being a really good cooperator, well then that’s extra good for you and you attract social partners, [00:34:30] both friends and romantic partners, and then you’re going to be more likely to pass your genes into the next generation if you get this reputation as a super good cooperator. 

So and there are a lot of good evolutionary reasons why we evolved to have these social preferences, both preferences to be part of fair transaction. So if you’re the proposer, you don’t want to be too stingy in your offer. Even in a case where you’re deciding whether to [00:35:00] share resources with another person and they actually don’t have the power to burn the money, so this would be called the dictator game. Even in the dictator game, when it’s a totally unilateral transaction, people will share 20% of the pie when they totally don’t have to, but we think that people do because it’s distasteful to be unfair when it benefits yourself. It’s more distasteful to be on the losing end of an unfair deal, but humans have [00:35:30] both what we call advantageous inequality aversion and disadvantageous inequality aversion, are sort of fancy ways of saying we don’t like being on the unbalanced and of an unfair deal, whether it’s advantageous or disadvantageous. But if we had to choose, we would prefer to be on top than on on the bottom. 

Nick Hanauer: Wow. So let’s turn to some of the stories that we tell ourselves, the ways in which we [00:36:00] reason morally about the economy. And in this episode we wanted to untangle this thing we call trickle down economics, which is broadly speaking, a set of explanations about how the economy works. Tax cuts for rich people create growth and wage increases for poor people, or the converse being tax increases on rich people will [00:36:30] kill jobs for poor people. 

And what’s super interesting about these arguments is that they’ve been used for a super long time in a billion circumstances, whether you’re litigating slavery, which was well, slavery is actually good for the slaves or litigating women’s suffrage, which is well, it would actually harm the women if we gave them the right to vote. We would give them the right to vote that that would be terrible for wherever it is. 

So you and I have talked a little bit about how that works, [00:37:00] but talk to us about why those arguments always take the same form. 

Molly Crockett: I find this argument really fascinating and I do want to say that I’m not at a macro economist, so I can’t provide any perspective on trickle down economics as a policy. But I do think that the language and narratives around these policies, and as you cogently point out, [00:37:30] how they seem to be similar in structure to narratives about other kinds of policies in the past that we have now come to realize were morally wrong. It’s fascinating because I think it really speaks to just how important morality is to all of us, how important it is to all of us to see ourselves and to convince other people that we’re the good guys. 

And I think it all goes back [00:38:00] to value based decision making. And as we were just discussing, although it’s true that the brain systems that compute value in decision making reflect moral concepts like fairness, I wouldn’t call those hardwired because hardwired implies fixed. And in fact, the research suggests [00:38:30] that the way we put values on things is very, very flexible. And it’s this flexibility in the way we construe our actions and how moral they are or how fair they are, I think that’s in some sense the Achilles heel of humanity because we’re so good at doing things that are very selfish, while at the same time convincing ourselves that we’re doing the most moral possible [00:39:00] thing.

And through that self-deception, convincing than other people in a very persuasive way that actually this is for the good of everyone. There are a lot of different examples. Some of examples I can give, Some of my favorite work on this is studies by Roberta Weber and Emily Haisley where they had people playing a game where it was sort of a simulation of a CEO having [00:39:30] decide whether to lay off workers. 

And you can imagine if you’re a CEO and you’re trying to improve your profit margin and you realize that you could lay off some workers and that would increase your profit margins, but you feel a little bit bad about doing that. So you look for evidence that if you lay off these workers, they’ll actually find a job again really quickly and they’ll be fine. And in their experiment, which is a [00:40:00] stylized version of this, what they found was that people’s estimation of how badly off the laid off employees would be was heavily biased by the outcome they wanted to achieve. 

So in the case where you really want to lay off the workers, you overestimate the probability that they’ll be able to find another job in the future. I’m paraphrasing this study, but that’s the general concept that I take away from [00:40:30] this. And psychology is just full of examples of how selective people are at processing information. So you could imagine economists searching a vast body of evidence, data on economies is vast, and there’s a lot of complex information to integrate. And time and time again, psychological research has shown that humans tend to pick the evidence that’s most favorable [00:41:00] to the answer that they want to get. 

Nick Hanauer: So one of my life goals is to help people inoculate themselves against this moral gaming of the system. In the perfect world, when somebody hears a phrase like, “It will harm the very people [00:41:30] it’s intended to help.” Alarm bells should start going off in your head. You should be like, “Why would they say that?”

Well, there is, I suppose a corner case possibility where directly helping somebody will harm them. Is that possible? Is it possible to inoculate people against these claims, that if we teach people about how this moral reasoning works, that they will be more attuned to the way in which other people are trying to [00:42:00] manipulate their psychology? Or is it hopeless, are we just all dumb animals, we’re just were little rats in cages and there’s no hope?

David Goldstein: Are you asking, Nick, how do we tell a better story?

Nick Hanauer: Well, maybe. I don’t know. Do you think there’s hope, Molly?

Molly Crockett: Yeah, I think it’s an interesting idea and I do think there’s hope. I think teaching people to recognize the structure of these narratives is an important first step and I think there must be examples of this, and I’m [00:42:30] drawing a blank as to a recent example, but the phrase, “The oldest story in the book,” this is something that we have in our culture. So I have to wash my hair. I can’t go out with you because I have to wash my hair. It’s cliche, it’s recognizable and so now if you don’t want to go out with somebody who is asking you out, you can’t really use that as an excuse because it’s recognizable as this cliche, right?  It may very well be possible [00:43:00] to educate people about this structure and then it’s certainly worth trying to do.

And more, broadly and I think also because we know that people are just fundamentally really, really, really sensitive to unfairness, the counter narrative like, “Well, even if lowering the taxes will increase your wages by a little bit, look what the top 0.1% are going to get from this. Are you cool [00:43:30] with that?” 

Nick Hanauer: Right. It’s sort of the ultimatum game writ large. I get 99, you get one. 

Molly Crockett: Yeah. You’re broadening out the perspective from, “Don’t you want to get one more than nothing?” to “How about you get one and we get 99?” that is a fundamentally different structure. And I know there are studies with variances of ultimatum game where people are willing to accept small amounts of money when they don’t know the size of the [00:44:00] pie. So hiding the size of the overall pie is actually a really effective way to get responders to accept unfair offers in the ultimatum game, but if they know how much the pie is and how much they’re missing out on, then they won’t accept that offer. 

Nick Hanauer: Interesting.

David Goldstein: So it turns out, Nick, that the socialists have the rhetoric intuitively right when they go after the 1%. And they’re going after rich people like you. That’s an effective moral argument.

Nick Hanauer: Yeah, yeah, for sure. And the enemy is the necessary part of the narrative.

David Goldstein: And that’s [00:44:30] why the Pitchforks are coming for.

Nick Hanauer: That’s right, exactly.

This has been a super fascinating conversation and really useful to us and our listeners, and so we want to thank you.

Molly Crockett: Thank you.

Nick Hanauer: Yeah, it’s was so fun to talk to you, Molly. 

David Goldstein: So the stories that structure of our economy are actually based on neurological structures of our brain.

Nick Hanauer: Yeah, it’s amazing. It doesn’t just get invented out of thin air. [00:45:00] The stories that we tell and except we’re evolved. Basically they’re a product of evolution, and biological evolution to a certain extent and cultural evolution too, and so they’re not random. They’re not surprising. They take the same form and the same way and the same circumstances again and again and again. And that awareness should lead us to examine these stories in a more careful way when we hear them.

David Goldstein: Right. The trick in trickled down, it turns out, is that [00:45:30] it exploits our deeply evolved human behavior.

Nick Hanauer: That’s right. And our need to be moral to see ourselves in a moral context to believe that the people who surround us are moral, to give plausible deniability to the people who are trying to take advantage of us. All of these things are essential to how these things operate. 

David Goldstein: Right. And that’s kind of depressing. Though on the bright side, if we know their trick, then we can use it to build a better story. 

Nick Hanauer: [00:46:00] I hope so. 

David Goldstein: I hope so too. 

Nick Hanauer: Yeah.

David Goldstein: So speaking of the impact of bad stories, Nick, next episode, we’re going to be asking the question: Whatever happened to the American middle-class?

Speaker 5: That should be a good episode.

Pitchfork Economics is produced by Civic Ventures. The magic happens in Seattle in partnership with Larj Media, that’s L-A-R-J media and The Young Turks network. 

Find [00:46:30] us on Twitter and Facebook @civicaction and follow our writing on Medium at Civic Skunk Works. And you should also follow Nick Hanauer on Twitter @NickHanauer. 

It’s always a big thank you to our guests and thank you to our team at Civic Ventures: Nick Hanauer, Zack Silk, Jasmine Weaver, Jessin Feral, Stephanie Urban, David Goldstein, Paul Constant, Nick Casella, and Annie Fadley.

Thanks fellas.

Comments (228)
  1. I just want to tell you that I’m newbie to blogging and absolutely savored you’re web-site. Almost certainly I’m planning to bookmark your blog post . You certainly have very good article content. Bless you for sharing with us your web page.

  2. I got what you mean , thankyou for putting up.Woh I am thankful to find this website through google. “It is a very hard undertaking to seek to please everybody.” by Publilius Syrus.

  3. Thanks for your article. It is rather unfortunate that over the last decade, the travel industry has had to take on terrorism, SARS, tsunamis, bird flu, swine flu, and also the first ever entire global downturn. Through it the industry has proven to be effective, resilient and also dynamic, acquiring new tips on how to deal with hardship. There are continually fresh challenges and opportunity to which the sector must yet again adapt and behave.

  4. Thank you for all of the hard work on this site. Ellie delights in doing investigation and it’s really easy to see why. A lot of people know all regarding the dynamic ways you convey very important ideas via your blog and increase response from other people on that article then my princess is undoubtedly starting to learn a lot of things. Have fun with the rest of the new year. You are doing a splendid job.

  5. Thanks for the article. I have usually observed that a lot of people are needing to lose weight since they wish to appear slim plus attractive. Nonetheless, they do not continually realize that there are many benefits for you to losing weight as well. Doctors declare that over weight people suffer from a variety of diseases that can be perfectely attributed to their particular excess weight. The good news is that people who sadly are overweight as well as suffering from different diseases are able to reduce the severity of their illnesses by simply losing weight. It is easy to see a steady but notable improvement in health when even a slight amount of weight reduction is attained.

  6. I was wondering if you ever considered changing the structure of your website? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having one or 2 pictures. Maybe you could space it out better?

  7. I definitely wanted to construct a small comment to appreciate you for these pleasant guidelines you are giving out here. My prolonged internet research has now been recognized with really good concept to exchange with my friends and family. I ‘d say that we site visitors actually are undoubtedly fortunate to exist in a great website with many outstanding individuals with interesting principles. I feel really blessed to have used the webpages and look forward to plenty of more fabulous times reading here. Thank you once more for all the details.

  8. I have not checked in here for a while as I thought it was getting boring, but the last several posts are great quality so I guess I’ll add you back to my everyday bloglist. You deserve it my friend 🙂

  9. Thanks for the sensible critique. Me and my neighbor were just preparing to do some research about this. We got a grab a book from our local library but I think I learned more clear from this post. I’m very glad to see such fantastic info being shared freely out there.

  10. There are some attention-grabbing deadlines in this article however I don’t know if I see all of them middle to heart. There is some validity but I will take hold opinion till I look into it further. Good article , thanks and we want extra! Added to FeedBurner as well

  11. I take pleasure in, lead to I discovered just what I was taking a look for. You’ve ended my four day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a great day. Bye

  12. Thanks for the guidelines shared in your blog. Something also important I would like to talk about is that fat loss is not exactly about going on a fad diet and trying to get rid of as much weight as possible in a few months. The most effective way in losing weight is by taking it little by little and using some basic suggestions which can assist you to make the most from a attempt to slim down. You may know and be following most of these tips, however reinforcing understanding never does any damage.

  13. I like what you guys are up also. Such intelligent work and reporting! Keep up the excellent works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it will improve the value of my website :).

  14. I simply wanted to develop a word to thank you for all of the stunning guides you are placing on this site. My time-consuming internet look up has finally been paid with high-quality details to exchange with my neighbours. I would assume that most of us readers actually are unquestionably blessed to live in a really good network with so many wonderful individuals with interesting solutions. I feel rather grateful to have discovered the weblog and look forward to many more cool moments reading here. Thank you once more for a lot of things.

  15. Someone necessarily lend a hand to make severely articles I might state. This is the very first time I frequented your website page and up to now? I amazed with the analysis you made to make this particular put up incredible. Magnificent job!

  16. Please let me know if you’re looking for a article author for your blog. You have some really good articles and I believe I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d love to write some content for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please send me an e-mail if interested. Cheers!

  17. Thank you, I have just been searching for info approximately this subject for ages and yours is the greatest I have discovered till now. However, what in regards to the bottom line? Are you certain in regards to the source?

  18. Thank you a lot for giving everyone such a breathtaking chance to discover important secrets from this web site. It’s always very lovely and also jam-packed with fun for me and my office friends to visit the blog a minimum of three times a week to read the new things you will have. Of course, I am also actually impressed considering the splendid techniques served by you. Certain 4 facts in this post are truly the best we’ve had.

  19. Almost all of the things you assert happens to be astonishingly appropriate and that makes me wonder the reason why I had not looked at this with this light before. This piece truly did turn the light on for me personally as far as this specific subject goes. Nonetheless there is 1 position I am not too cozy with so while I make an effort to reconcile that with the core theme of your position, allow me see just what the rest of your readers have to say.Well done.

  20. Hi, i read your blog from time to time and i own a similar one and i was just curious if you get a lot of spam feedback? If so how do you stop it, any plugin or anything you can recommend? I get so much lately it’s driving me mad so any assistance is very much appreciated.

  21. Thanks for the ideas shared on your blog. Yet another thing I would like to express is that weight loss is not information about going on a dietary fad and trying to lose as much weight as possible in a couple of days. The most effective way to shed pounds is by using it slowly and gradually and obeying some basic ideas which can provide help to make the most from the attempt to lose fat. You may learn and already be following most of these tips, nonetheless reinforcing knowledge never hurts.

  22. Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it. Look advanced to far added agreeable from you! However, how could we communicate?

  23. Hello there! I know this is kinda off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are you using for this site? I’m getting sick and tired of WordPress because I’ve had problems with hackers and I’m looking at alternatives for another platform. I would be fantastic if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

  24. I cherished as much as you’ll obtain performed right here. The cartoon is attractive, your authored subject matter stylish. nevertheless, you command get got an shakiness over that you wish be delivering the following. unwell for sure come more earlier once more since exactly the same just about very regularly within case you shield this hike.

  25. I have seen a great deal of useful factors on your web-site about computers. However, I’ve the judgment that lap tops are still less than powerful more than enough to be a wise decision if you generally do tasks that require a great deal of power, for instance video touch-ups. But for world wide web surfing, statement processing, and the majority of other popular computer functions they are fine, provided you don’t mind the tiny screen size. Thank you for sharing your opinions.

  26. Hello my friend! I want to say that this article is awesome, nice written and include almost all important infos. I’d like to look more posts like this .

  27. Hello, you used to write wonderful, but the last several posts have been kinda boring… I miss your great writings. Past several posts are just a little out of track! come on!

  28. Hello there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it is truly informative. I’m going to watch out for brussels. I will appreciate if you continue this in future. A lot of people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

  29. I’m curious to find out what blog system you have been working with? I’m having some minor security problems with my latest website and I’d like to find something more risk-free. Do you have any recommendations?

  30. Thanks for sharing superb informations. Your web site is very cool. I am impressed by the details that you¡¦ve on this web site. It reveals how nicely you understand this subject. Bookmarked this web page, will come back for more articles. You, my pal, ROCK! I found just the info I already searched all over the place and simply couldn’t come across. What an ideal website.

  31. I will immediately clutch your rss as I can not in finding your e-mail subscription hyperlink or e-newsletter service. Do you’ve any? Please permit me realize so that I may just subscribe. Thanks.

  32. What i do not realize is actually how you’re not actually a lot more well-liked than you might be right now. You are so intelligent. You understand therefore significantly with regards to this topic, made me individually consider it from so many varied angles. Its like men and women are not interested unless it¡¦s something to do with Girl gaga! Your personal stuffs nice. At all times deal with it up!

  33. I used to be very pleased to seek out this net-site.I wanted to thanks on your time for this glorious learn!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to take a look at new stuff you blog post.

  34. What i don’t understood is actually how you’re not actually a lot more well-preferred than you may be now. You’re very intelligent. You understand thus considerably when it comes to this topic, produced me for my part consider it from numerous various angles. Its like men and women don’t seem to be involved except it’s one thing to do with Woman gaga! Your own stuffs great. Always take care of it up!

  35. Simply desire to say your article is as astounding. The clarity for your submit is simply excellent and that i can think you are knowledgeable on this subject. Well along with your permission let me to seize your RSS feed to stay up to date with coming near near post. Thanks a million and please carry on the enjoyable work.

  36. Greetings! Quick question that’s completely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My weblog looks weird when viewing from my apple iphone. I’m trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to resolve this problem. If you have any recommendations, please share. Cheers!

  37. Whats up are using WordPress for your site platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and create my own. Do you require any coding expertise to make your own blog? Any help would be greatly appreciated!

  38. I believe this website has some rattling superb info for everyone. “It is easy enough to define what the Commonwealth is not. Indeed this is quite a popular pastime.” by Elizabeth II.

  39. Its like you read my mind! You seem to know so much about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home a little bit, but other than that, this is great blog. An excellent read. I will certainly be back.

  40. What i don’t understood is actually how you’re not actually much more well-liked than you may be now. You are so intelligent. You realize thus significantly relating to this subject, made me personally consider it from a lot of varied angles. Its like women and men aren’t fascinated unless it is one thing to accomplish with Lady gaga! Your own stuffs outstanding. Always maintain it up!

  41. I loved as much as you’ll receive carried out right here. The sketch is tasteful, your authored material stylish. nonetheless, you command get got an nervousness over that you wish be turning in the following. ill surely come further in the past once more as exactly the similar just about very frequently inside case you defend this increase.

  42. Do you have a spam issue on this website; I also am a blogger, and I was wondering your situation; many of us have created some nice methods and we are looking to exchange techniques with others, be sure to shoot me an e-mail if interested.

  43. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wished to say that I have really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again very soon!

  44. Can I just say what a comfort to discover somebody who really knows what they are discussing on the internet. You certainly realize how to bring a problem to light and make it important. More and more people have to look at this and understand this side of your story. I was surprised you aren’t more popular because you definitely possess the gift.

  45. I really like your writing style, excellent info, regards for putting up :D. “Faith is a continuation of reason.” by William Adams.

  46. I have recently started a website, the information you offer on this website has helped me greatly. Thanks for all of your time & work. “Everyone is responsible and no one is to blame.” by Will Schutz.

  47. Hey there! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site with us so I came to give it a look. I’m definitely loving the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Exceptional blog and excellent design and style.

  48. I have to show some thanks to you for bailing me out of such a circumstance. Right after researching through the world-wide-web and seeing ideas which were not pleasant, I figured my life was over. Existing without the presence of answers to the difficulties you have resolved through your good write-up is a critical case, as well as the kind that might have badly damaged my entire career if I hadn’t encountered the website. Your own personal know-how and kindness in playing with every aspect was precious. I’m not sure what I would’ve done if I hadn’t come upon such a solution like this. I am able to at this point look ahead to my future. Thank you very much for this specialized and sensible guide. I will not be reluctant to recommend your web blog to anyone who should have guidelines about this subject matter.

  49. I’ve been surfing online more than three hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It is pretty worth enough for me. Personally, if all web owners and bloggers made good content as you did, the web will be a lot more useful than ever before.

  50. I’m truly enjoying the design and layout of your site. It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more pleasant for me to come here and visit more often. Did you hire out a developer to create your theme? Superb work!

  51. Nice blog here! Also your web site loads up very fast! What host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my website loaded up as fast as yours lol

  52. Hello there! This article couldn’t be written any better! Reading through
    this post reminds me of my previous roommate!
    He always kept talking about this. I’ll send this information to him.
    Fairly certain he’ll have a good read. Thanks for sharing!

  53. I used to be very pleased to find this internet-site.I wished to thanks for your time for this wonderful learn!! I undoubtedly enjoying each little bit of it and I’ve you bookmarked to take a look at new stuff you weblog post.

  54. I wish to show some thanks to this writer just for bailing me out of this situation. Because of researching throughout the world wide web and seeing thoughts which were not powerful, I thought my life was done. Existing without the strategies to the issues you’ve resolved all through your main guide is a crucial case, as well as the kind that might have negatively affected my entire career if I had not come across your web site. Your main capability and kindness in dealing with the whole thing was excellent. I’m not sure what I would have done if I had not come across such a step like this. I can at this time look forward to my future. Thanks very much for the expert and sensible guide. I will not think twice to endorse the sites to any individual who wants and needs support on this situation.

  55. Thanks for this article. I will also like to say that it can always be hard while you are in school and merely starting out to create a long credit standing. There are many learners who are simply trying to pull through and have an extended or beneficial credit history can often be a difficult point to have.

  56. Hey! Someone in my Facebook group shared this site with us so I came to take a look. I’m definitely loving the information. I’m bookmarking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Excellent blog and terrific style and design. Hi, I read your blogs daily. Your humoristic style is awesome, keep it up! This is a topic that is close to my heart… Thank you!

  57. Howdy very cool blog!! Guy .. Excellent .. Superb .. I’ll bookmark your blog and take the feeds also…I’m satisfied to find a lot of useful information here within the put up, we want develop more strategies on this regard, thank you for sharing.

  58. Hey there! I’ve been reading your blog for a while now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Porter Tx! Just wanted to tell you keep up the good work!

  59. of course like your web-site however you have to take a look at the spelling on several of your posts. A number of them are rife with spelling issues and I to find it very troublesome to inform the reality however I will certainly come again again.

  60. Hey there just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The text in your content seem to be running off the screen in Internet explorer. I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I figured I’d post to let you know. The layout look great though! Hope you get the problem resolved soon. Cheers

  61. Now that you find out about video editing and the what exactly you need you are prepared to begin with the journey of amateur filmmaker to professional director. It took about a few months to master the language along with the raucous, discordant (to my ears) “melody. Instead of enjoying karaoke parties, it is possible to always take the music and build your personal song, by plugging it in your TV sets.

  62. Greetings from Ohio! I’m bored at work so I decided to browse your blog on my iphone during lunch break. I love the knowledge you present here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m shocked at how quick your blog loaded on my phone .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyhow, great site!

  63. Thank you for another magnificent article. Where else could anybody get that kind of info in such an ideal way of writing? I’ve a presentation next week, and I’m on the look for such info.

  64. Thanks for some other great article. The place else may anyone get that type of information in such a perfect way of writing? I have a presentation subsequent week, and I’m at the search for such info.

  65. Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all people you actually recognise what you’re talking approximately! Bookmarked. Please also consult with my web site =). We may have a link change agreement between us!

  66. Thanks for every other great post. Where else may just anyone get that type of info in such a perfect approach of writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and I’m on the look for such information.

  67. Hey! Do you know if they make any plugins to safeguard against hackers? I’m kinda paranoid about losing everything I’ve worked hard on. Any recommendations?

  68. After I initially commented I clicked the -Notify me when new feedback are added- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four emails with the identical comment. Is there any way you’ll be able to take away me from that service? Thanks!

  69. I have recently started a blog, the info you provide on this website has helped me tremendously. Thank you for all of your time & work. “A physicist is an atom’s way of knowing about atoms.” by George Wald.

  70. It’s really a nice and useful piece of info. I am happy that you simply shared this helpful information with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.

  71. What’s Going down i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I have discovered It absolutely useful and it has aided me out loads. I hope to contribute & aid different customers like its helped me. Great job.

  72. What i do not realize is if truth be told how you are not actually much more well-favored than you might be now. You’re so intelligent. You realize thus considerably with regards to this topic, made me personally imagine it from numerous varied angles. Its like women and men aren’t involved except it is one thing to accomplish with Lady gaga! Your personal stuffs nice. At all times care for it up!

  73. That is the proper blog for anyone who desires to seek out out about this topic. You realize a lot its almost laborious to argue with you (not that I really would want…HaHa). You definitely put a new spin on a topic thats been written about for years. Nice stuff, simply great!

  74. Nearly all of the things you mention happens to be supprisingly legitimate and it makes me ponder the reason why I hadn’t looked at this in this light before. Your piece really did turn the light on for me as far as this specific topic goes. However at this time there is one particular position I am not necessarily too comfy with so while I make an effort to reconcile that with the central idea of the position, allow me see what all the rest of the subscribers have to point out.Nicely done.

  75. hello there and thank you for your info – I have definitely picked up anything new from right here. I did however expertise a few technical points using this web site, as I experienced to reload the web site many times previous to I could get it to load properly. I had been wondering if your web hosting is OK? Not that I’m complaining, but sluggish loading instances times will sometimes affect your placement in google and could damage your high-quality score if ads and marketing with Adwords. Well I am adding this RSS to my email and can look out for a lot more of your respective intriguing content. Ensure that you update this again very soon..

  76. I think this is one of the most important info for me. And i am glad reading your article. But should remark on few general things, The web site style is perfect, the articles is really nice : D. Good job, cheers

  77. Thank you for sharing excellent informations. Your site is so cool. I am impressed by the details that you’ve on this site. It reveals how nicely you perceive this subject. Bookmarked this website page, will come back for more articles. You, my friend, ROCK! I found simply the information I already searched all over the place and simply could not come across. What a great site.

  78. Hi, i think that i saw you visited my weblog so i got here to “go back the want”.I’m attempting to in finding issues to enhance my site!I guess its ok to make use of a few of your concepts!!

  79. Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your web site and in accession capital to assert that I acquire actually enjoyed account your blog posts. Any way I will be subscribing to your augment and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.

  80. What i do not understood is in reality how you’re not really much more well-preferred than you may be now. You are so intelligent. You realize thus significantly with regards to this matter, made me for my part believe it from so many numerous angles. Its like men and women aren’t fascinated unless it¡¦s one thing to accomplish with Lady gaga! Your own stuffs outstanding. All the time care for it up!

  81. I’ve been exploring for a little bit for any high quality articles or blog posts in this kind of space . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this web site. Reading this information So i am satisfied to show that I have a very just right uncanny feeling I found out exactly what I needed. I so much without a doubt will make sure to do not overlook this website and give it a glance on a relentless basis.

  82. you are actually a excellent webmaster. The website loading speed is amazing. It sort of feels that you are doing any unique trick. In addition, The contents are masterpiece. you have performed a great process on this topic!

  83. hey there and thank you for your information – I’ve definitely picked up anything new from right here. I did however expertise some technical issues using this web site, as I experienced to reload the site many times previous to I could get it to load properly. I had been wondering if your hosting is OK? Not that I am complaining, but sluggish loading instances times will sometimes affect your placement in google and can damage your quality score if advertising and marketing with Adwords. Anyway I’m adding this RSS to my email and could look out for a lot more of your respective intriguing content. Make sure you update this again soon..

  84. Hi there are using WordPress for your blog platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and set up my own. Do you need any coding knowledge to make your own blog? Any help would be really appreciated!

  85. Do you mind if I quote a few of your articles as long as I provide credit and sources back to your weblog? My blog site is in the very same area of interest as yours and my users would truly benefit from a lot of the information you present here. Please let me know if this okay with you. Cheers!

  86. It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I’d without a doubt donate to this excellent blog! I suppose for now i’ll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to fresh updates and will share this site with my Facebook group. Chat soon!

  87. Hi my friend! I wish to say that this article is amazing, nice written and include approximately all important infos. I’d like to see more posts like this.

  88. Howdy just wanted to give you a quick heads up and let you know a few of the pictures aren’t loading properly. I’m not sure why but I think its a linking issue. I’ve tried it in two different browsers and both show the same results.

  89. I was wondering if you ever thought of changing the page layout of your blog? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having one or two pictures. Maybe you could space it out better?

  90. Today, I went to the beachfront with my kids. I found a sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She put the shell to her ear and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear. She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is completely off topic but I had to tell someone!

  91. Hello, i think that i saw you visited my weblog so i came to “return the favor”.I’m attempting to find things to improve my site!I suppose its ok to use a few of your ideas!!

  92. Thank you for this article. I would also like to convey that it can end up being hard when you are in school and starting out to create a long history of credit. There are many college students who are simply trying to make it and have an extended or favourable credit history can occasionally be a difficult thing to have.

  93. It’s really a great and useful piece of information. I’m happy that you simply shared this helpful information with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.

  94. Magnificent goods from you, man. I have take into accout your stuff previous to and you are simply too wonderful. I really like what you have received right here, really like what you are stating and the way in which during which you are saying it. You make it enjoyable and you continue to take care of to stay it smart. I cant wait to read far more from you. That is really a terrific site.

  95. Hi, Neat post. There’s an issue together with your web
    site in internet explorer, may test this?
    IE still is the marketplace chief and a big part
    of folks will miss your magnificent writing because of this problem.

  96. Thank you for some other informative blog. Where else may I get that type of information written in such a perfect approach?
    I’ve a undertaking that I’m just now running on, and I have been on the look out for such info.

  97. I would like to thank you for the efforts you’ve put in writing this website. I am hoping the same high-grade site post from you in the upcoming as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to get my own blog now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings quickly. Your write up is a great example of it.

  98. Hey! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog
    to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good success.
    If you know of any please share. Appreciate it!

  99. Greate pieces. Keep writing such kind of info on your site.
    Im really impressed by your blog.
    Hey there, You’ve done a fantastic job. I will definitely digg it and for my part
    suggest to my friends. I’m confident they will be benefited from this site.

  100. Amazing! This blog looks exactly like my old one! It’s on a totally different topic but it has pretty much the same page layout and design. Outstanding choice of colors!

  101. This is very worthwhile, you’re a very skilled blogger.I have joined your rss feed and look forward to reading more of your excellent post.Also, I have shared your website in my social networks!

  102. Thank you a lot for giving everyone an extremely superb possiblity to read articles and blog posts from this site. It can be very great and as well , full of a great time for me and my office acquaintances to search the blog nearly 3 times per week to read the newest stuff you have got. And definitely, I’m just actually contented with the astounding guidelines you give. Selected 1 facts in this article are without a doubt the finest we’ve had.

  103. Aw, this was a very nice post. In thought I wish to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and precise effort to make an excellent article… however what can I say… I procrastinate alot and not at all seem to get one thing done.

  104. Thanks for the sensible critique. Me and my neighbor were just preparing to do some research on this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I think I learned more clear from this post. I’m very glad to see such fantastic information being shared freely out there.

  105. Now that you find out about video editing and the what exactly you need you are prepared to begin with the journey of amateur filmmaker to professional director. It took about a few months to master the language along with the raucous, discordant (to my ears) “melody. Instead of enjoying karaoke parties, it is possible to always take the music and build your personal song, by plugging it in your TV sets.

  106. Hello there! This post could not be written any better! Reading this post reminds me of my old room mate! He always kept talking about this. I will forward this post to him. Pretty sure he will have a good read. Thanks for sharing!

  107. Hello! I’ve been reading your blog for a while now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Humble Tx! Just wanted to tell you keep up the fantastic work!

  108. Whats up very nice web site!! Man .. Beautiful .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your website and take the feeds additionally…I’m happy to seek out a lot of helpful information right here in the put up, we want develop extra strategies on this regard, thank you for sharing. . . . . .

  109. Hi, i read your blog occasionally and i own a similar one and i was just wondering if you get a lot of spam remarks? If so how do you reduce it, any plugin or anything you can recommend? I get so much lately it’s driving me crazy so any support is very much appreciated.

  110. I’m not sure the place you’re getting your info, however great topic. I needs to spend some time finding out much more or figuring out more. Thank you for magnificent info I used to be in search of this information for my mission.

  111. I loved as much as you’ll receive carried out right here.
    The sketch is attractive, your authored subject matter
    stylish. nonetheless, you command get bought an shakiness
    over that you wish be delivering the following.
    unwell unquestionably come more formerly again since
    exactly the same nearly very often inside case you shield this
    increase.

  112. I like the helpful info you provide in your articles. I will bookmark your weblog and check again here regularly. I’m quite certain I’ll learn plenty of new stuff right here! Good luck for the next!

  113. I take pleasure in, cause I found just what I used to be having a look for. You’ve ended my 4 day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a nice day. Bye

  114. Can I just say what a comfort to discover somebody who really knows what they are discussing on the internet. You certainly realize how to bring a problem to light and make it important. More and more people have to look at this and understand this side of your story. I was surprised you aren’t more popular because you definitely possess the gift.

  115. I have acquired some new things from your web site about pcs. Another thing I have always assumed is that laptop computers have become a product that each residence must have for most reasons. They offer convenient ways to organize the home, pay bills, shop, study, hear music and in many cases watch television shows. An innovative approach to complete every one of these tasks is to use a computer. These computers are mobile ones, small, highly effective and convenient.

  116. I’ve been exploring for a bit for any high quality articles or blog posts on this kind of area . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this site. Reading this information So i am happy to convey that I’ve a very good uncanny feeling I discovered exactly what I needed. I most certainly will make sure to do not forget this website and give it a look regularly.

  117. Have you ever considered creating an ebook or guest authoring on other blogs? I have a blog based on the same information you discuss and would love to have you share some stories/information. I know my visitors would appreciate your work. If you’re even remotely interested, feel free to send me an e mail.

  118. Hi there, simply become aware of your blog through Google, and located that it is truly informative. I am going to watch out for brussels. I’ll appreciate if you proceed this in future. A lot of other folks shall be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

  119. I’ve been surfing on-line greater than 3 hours nowadays, but I by no means discovered any fascinating article like yours. It’s lovely worth sufficient for me. In my opinion, if all webmasters and bloggers made excellent content material as you did, the net might be a lot more useful than ever before.

  120. Outstanding post however I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this subject? I’d be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit further. Cheers!

  121. I truly enjoy reading on this internet site, it has got fantastic content. “The living is a species of the dead and not a very attractive one.” by Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *